Wednesday, May 21, 2025

U.S. court dismisses $58 million Nigeria lawsuit in victory for Shell

Law firm Haynes Boone defended The Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Limited (SPDC), now known as Renaissance Africa Energy Company (RAEC), against a $58 million lawsuit, securing a complete dismissal in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

Nigerian contractor Forstech Technical Nigeria Limited sued SPDC under the Alien Tort Claims Act (Case: 1:24-cv-07629), claiming SPDC owed over $58 million in processing fees related to a contract between Forstech and the Bayelsa State government.

The court dismissed the suit for lack of personal jurisdiction. The court found that the claims, which focused entirely on conduct in Nigeria, lacked a sufficient connection to New York to establish jurisdiction.

Haynes Boone Associate Rebecca Schwarz led the litigation team and crafted the successful motion to dismiss. Litigation Partner Michael Mazzone and Appellate Partner Mark Trachtenberg provided additional support.

“We’re proud to have secured a clean dismissal for our client,” Schwarz said. “The court's analysis reinforces important jurisdictional boundaries that prevent U.S. courts from becoming a forum for every international business dispute.”

‘Difficult choices’: aid cuts threaten effort to reduce maternal deaths in Nigeria

At a UN-run antenatal clinic in a camp for people displaced by Boko Haram, the colours stand out like the bellies of the pregnant women. Abayas in neon green, dark brown and shades of yellow graze against the purple and white uniforms of nurses attending to them in the beige-orange halls of the maternal healthcare facility.

Within the clinic in Maiduguri in north-east Nigeria, midwives and nurses are handing out free emergency home delivery kits, “dignity kits” for sexual abuse survivors and reusable sanitary pads to curb exploitation of young girls who cannot afford them.

A dozen women sit on a mat in the corridor, awaiting the start of a session on reproductive health and doing their best to stay focused in the unwavering 42C heat. Among them is Yangana Mohammed, a smiling 32-year-old mother of seven who knits bama caps for a living.

“I like that the services are free,” she said, holding a yellow medical card while waiting to change her birth control implant. “I’m really glad for this clinic.”

Five years ago, when Mohammed fled jihadist violence in her home town of Gom, she had never heard of family planning. In Muna, a settlement with a couple of thousand residents, down from more than 17,000 at the peak of the insurgency, she found the clinic. It was suggested by her husband, a volunteer for the local vigilante group backed by the state in fighting jihadists, after her last delivery two years ago.

A kilometre away, Aisha, a 25-year-old mother of two, waits her turn at a state-run facility supported by Unicef. Her husband previously barred her from attending antenatal classes, worried that discussing an unborn child with outsiders could harm the foetus. But after losing so much blood in her last pregnancy that five bags had to be transfused into her veins, he quickly changed his mind.

Experts say more resources are needed to sustain such success stories in a region struggling with high maternal mortality, child marriage and female genital mutilation rates. UN global data for 2023, the most recent available, shows that Nigeria recorded 75,000 maternal deaths that year – nearly a third of the total worldwide.

Many of those cases are among north-east Nigeria’s estimated 45 million people. Ritgak Tilley-Gyado, an Abuja-based senior health specialist at the World Bank, said disparities were fuelled by inequities in health systems and socioeconomic and sociocultural status across the country.

“As a result, a woman in the north-east of the country is 10 times more likely to die from childbirth than her counterpart in the south-west … [with] a systems approach that tugs on the right levers, we can turn these abysmal numbers around and improve the wellbeing of mothers,” she said.

The rampant acute malnutrition in the region has worsened things, said Trond Jensen, the head of the UN Office for Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (Ocha) in Maiduguri.

“At many of [our] stabilisation centres for severely acute malnourished children, the mothers are very young … the risk of maternal mortality increases when you start having children very young and you have inadequate birth spacing, which then leads to complications,” he said.

Across the region, basic infrastructure has been strained or destroyed by a 15-year insurgency spearheaded by Boko Haram and its splinter group Islamic State West Africa Province (ISWAP).

Meanwhile, Nigeria’s federal health budget can hardly match the scale of assistance needed: USAID contributions surpassed Nigeria’s federal allocations for health between 2022 and 2024. In many remote areas cut off by jihadist violence, there is little or no access to health services, forcing nonprofits to sometimes use helicopters to deliver emergency relief.

Aid workers are scrambling to deliver more successes with fewer resources.

For 2024, the UN’s humanitarian response plan of $927m was only half funded. There are fears about bigger funding gaps for this year’s plan since the dismantling of USAID, which paid for 60% of all humanitarian programmes in north-east Nigeria last year. Other donors including the UK, Germany and the Netherlands have also cut down their aid packages or are planning to, in the biggest reshaping of foreign aid in recent history.

“Unfortunately … that has meant that, for instance, 70% of health facilities that we are providing assistance through have been impacted,” said Jensen.

Some providers of humanitarian services are in a state of near panic about the approaching lean season – the period between harvests – which is usually from June to September.

“We have just short of 5 million people who are in need of food assistance … I think the latest estimate is that 23,000 children will be at risk of dying this lean season,” said Jensen, whose agency has begun rigorous cost-cutting and is asking donors to “fund our local partners directly, because that reduces transaction costs”.

“We have to make extremely difficult choices,” he said.

At the clinic, Mohammed has no idea of the behind-the-scenes struggle to keep the free services in place.

“From the knowledge the women here teach me, I pass on [advice about puberty and personal hygiene] to Hafsa, my 16-year-old daughter, who is like my friend,” says Mohammed, who hopes the clinic is around long enough for her daughter to use it.

By Eromo Egbejule, The Guardian

Tuesday, May 20, 2025

Nigeria's fierce political rivals share joke at pope's inaugural mass


 







Fierce Nigerian political rivals Peter Obi and President Bola Tinubu were seen laughing and joking at Pope Leo XIV's inaugural mass in Rome.

Tinubu of the All Progressives Congress defeated Obi of the Labour Party in the heated and tightly contested 2023 presidential election - a victory Obi challenged at the Supreme Court without success.

The pair's supporters have expressed bitter rivalry towards each other over the years, both on social media and on the streets, with some physical clashes occurring prior to the elections.

Tinubu and Obi are expected to go head-to-head again in less than two years' time as Nigeria prepares for another election in 2027.

Photos of the meeting were shared by presidential spokesman Bayo Onanuga on social media, who recounted what transpired when Obi and a former governor greeted the Nigerian president after seeing him at the event.

"Mr President, welcome to our church, and thank you for honouring the Pope with your presence," said former Ekiti state governor Kayode Fayemi.

Both Obi and Fayemi are Catholics, while Tinubu is Muslim.

However, President Tinubu responded: "I should be the one welcoming you and Peter. I'm the head of the Nigerian delegation."

The president's response elicited laughter from Obi, who agreed.

"Yes, indeed. We are members of your delegation," Obi said.

Despite the memorable encounter, Obi did not mention it in his long post on X about his visit to the Vatican.

Alkassim Hussain, a member of Nigeria's House of Representatives, told the BBC that the light-hearted meeting was good for the country's politics and should help reduce tension.

"They portrayed a good image of the country and that's how politics should be played - without bitterness.

"I hope supporters of both Tinubu and Obi can see that after elections and court cases, then it is all about the country and how everyone can join hands together to grow it," he noted.

Tinubu won the 2023 elections after the opposition was split between the Labour Party and the Peoples Democratic Party.

There is speculation that the two parties could form a coalition in 2027 to challenge Tinubu, who is expected to seek a second term.

Elections are often marred by violence in Nigeria, with hundreds of people losing their lives since the country's return to democracy in 1999.

By Mansur Abubakar, BBC

Nigeria's first film in Cannes lineup explores masculinity, family dynamics

















CANNES, France, May 19 (Reuters) - With "My Father's Shadow," Nigeria's first film in the Cannes Film Festival's official selection, director Akinola Davies Jr. wanted to create something deeply personal, he told Reuters.

The film had to mean "something to me, to him (my brother), to my family, to our community, I guess to masculinity in general," said Davies about the film competing in the second-tier Un Certain Regard category that he wrote with his brother, Wale.

Davies' first feature takes place over one day in 1993, when two brothers' absent father, played by "Gangs of London" star Sope Dirisu, shows up unannounced and takes them to Lagos.

Their father is there to try to recoup some money owed from his employer as the country is on edge after the outcome of the first elections in a decade under military rule is annulled.

Newcomers and real-life brothers Godwin Egbo, 11 at the time of filming, and Chibuike Marvellous Egbo, then 8, play the young siblings in the semi-autobiographical film that's been picked up for distribution by streamer Mubi.

"Nigeria was going through a time where there was a lot of enthusiasm for this idea of a statesman who was going to lead us to potential," similar to the boys' relationship with their father, said Davies, who was raised between London and Lagos.

"Both things being so sort of strong and dominant, but equally super vulnerable and super fragile - I think the tension sort of played off each other really well," said Davies.

Dirisu, a British actor born to Nigerian parents, said that the film made him take a deeper look at what it means to be a father as well as how Nigeria fits into his personal identity.

"There were a lot of things I had to interrogate for the role, but it was exciting," the actor told Reuters.


MORE AFRICAN STORIES

Davies' film is one of several strong contenders competing in Un Certain Regard this year, with actors Harrison DickinsonKristen Stewart and Scarlett Johansson also in the race with their directorial debuts.

The Guardian gave "My Father's Shadow" four out of five stars, calling it a "subtle and intelligent coming-of-age tale" while industry publication IndieWire gave the "beautifully remembered drama" the grade of B+.

Davies hopes the movie's inclusion at Cannes will pave the way for more African films at the festival.
"African stories are out there," he told Reuters, but they need to be able to get to festivals like Cannes to be seen.

When there's willingness from other areas of the world, and points of access, however, those films can come through, he said.

Hanna Rantala and Miranda Murray, Reuters

Nigeria seeks to boost cocoa exports as oil falters


 








Almost four decades after Nigeria dispensed with a cocoa-industry regulatory board in 1986, a new executive bill is working its way to the legislature to create a replacement. By the time it was scrapped, the cocoa marketing board, which fixed prices and regulated other industry practices, was so hated by farmers that it was seen as the primary obstacle to their progress.

Thirty-nine years later, the government is preparing for the launch of a new regulatory body. On 5 May agriculture minister Abubakar Kyari announced that President Bola Tinubu’s cabinet has approved a draft bill to create a National Cocoa Management Board that will have responsibility for regulating the industry, but without the power to fix prices.

“With this new framework, we will be competing directly with top global producers like Ghana and Côte d’Ivoire,” said Kyari.

For President Bola Tinubu’s government, this is a chance to boost the potential of an industry that has broken several price records in recent years, with prices rising 400% in three years to reach $12,000 per ton at point. The value of cocoa exports from Nigeria jumped more than sevenfold between 2023 and 2024 to 2.7 trillion naira ($1.7bn), driven by higher demand and naira depreciation. Cocoa thus offers Nigeria a viable opportunity to diversify away from faltering oil exports.

The Tinubu administration based its 2025 budget of 54.9 trillion naira on a daily oil output of 2.06m barrels of crude sold at $75 per barrel. While the year started with a January production of 1.53m barrels per day, it has remained below that number in the subsequent months, with prices closer to $60 a barrel. Thoughts are therefore turning to cocoa as a potential driver of export earnings.


Demands for better traceability

Though Nigerian cocoa farmers and the industry in general have enjoyed the freedom to set prices, Nigerian-origin cocoa has sometimes been sold at a discount due to quality inconsistency, an indicator of variable industry standards. But recent global developments demanding sustainable and ethical practices, particularly the introduction of the European Union Deforestation Regulation, made regulated standards a necessity.

The Regulation, passed by the European Parliament in 2023, requires all exporters of agricultural commodities to the EU to provide evidence that the crop is grown sustainably and is not causing deforestation. It requires that agricultural exports be traceable to where they are grown – and this requirement has made a regulator essential, according to Adeola Adegoke, president of the Cocoa Farmers Association of Nigeria. “The Nigerian cocoa industry cannot continue to be on autopilot,” said Adegoke. “There must be a deliberate plan to reposition it in order to regain the lost glory of the cocoa economy.” Nigeria slipped from its leadership in cocoa production as oil became the mainstay of the economy from the 1970s, and agricultural exports were sidelined by successive governments.


More support needed for farmers

In recent years, the trade has suffered from an absence of incentives and government support, especially in the years in which farmers were threatened by price volatility, said Adegoke. The major assignment of the board will be to fill that gap, he said.

The move toward a new board started with the establishment of the National Cocoa Management Committee in August 2022. Made up of industry stakeholders and officials of the agriculture ministry, its primary task was to devise measures for the revitalisation of cocoa as a major export commodity.

The committee identified significant challenges, such as difficulties in dealing with cocoa pests and diseases, a growing preponderance of ageing plantations and farmers, lack of finance and the absence of national regulation.

In the draft bill, the National Cocoa Management Committee will be converted into the National Cocoa Management Board to tackle the identified problems facing the industry.


High prices bring opportunities

The more than threefold increase in cocoa prices between 2023 and 2024 seems to have been a wake-up call for the government. Nigeria has ranked fifth in recent years among global cocoa producers, behind Côte d’Ivoire, Ghana, Ecuador and Cameroon. While the two top producers, Côte d’Ivoire and Ghana, suffered significant output shortfalls due to unfavourable weather, Nigeria, which had a better crop, lacked the output scale to make the most of the opportunity.

Still, the country produced more than 300,000 tons of the crop in the 2023-24 season. Some expect an even better harvest in the current season due to improved weather. The government is keen to capitalise on this.

Prices for cocoa futures have started retreating from their record levels, and were ranging between $7,844 and $8,415 per ton in March, according to a market assessment published on 11 April by the International Cocoa Organization (ICCO).

Weighing on the market were weakening demand and an expectation that most of the West African producers, who account for 70% of global production, will have a better season than the 2023-24 season. The current season is the first in three years in which the ICCO is expecting a production surplus. But it is unlikely to result in a wholesale reset of prices, given the vagaries of the supply chain.

Indeed, with hedge funds betting on cocoa futures and driving the record prices of recent years, younger people in Nigeria are beginning to see a future in cocoa farms. Some are establishing new farms and planting early-maturing varieties that yield pods within three years, according to officials at the Cocoa Association of Nigeria (CAN).

Yet, even while the government has been applauded for initiating the return of an industry board, some stakeholders have their misgivings.

Sayanna Riman, a cocoa farmer and a former president of the CAN, which groups farmers, buyers and processors, says that a board could lead to creeping government interference that ultimately may not be in the interest of farmers. What the industry needs, rather than an interfering body, Riman says, is more sensitivity to the challenges that farmers face and targeted support to help them make the most of the era of high prices. “What the cocoa industry needs is investments and more standardisation,” Riman concludes.

By Dulue Mbachu, African Business